25 Old-Fashioned Amish Recipes

Looking for some delicious and easy Amish recipes? These old-fashioned dishes are simple yet truly special. They’re made with simple, home-grown ingredients, but each dish is packed with flavor. It’s amazing how something so straightforward can taste so good!

1.Amish Breakfast Casserole

Hey there! Looking for a breakfast that’s anything but basic? This hearty breakfast casserole is loaded with hash browns, bacon, and a trio of cheeses–cheddar, cottage, and Swiss. It’s not your average casserole, folks.

With three types of cheese, it’s not just rich and cheesy–it’s legendary. Get ready to start your day with a dish that’s anything but ordinary!

2.Amish Onion Patties

These onion patties are a simple delight that packs a big flavor punch. The mix of sweet and spicy, tender and crunchy textures creates a mouthwatering experience you’ll crave.

Whether you dip them in ketchup, salsa, or my personal favorite–sour cream–they’re irresistible. And honestly, I wouldn’t have it any other way… onion breath and all!

3.Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken and Dumplings

Cozy up with this classic Pennsylvania Dutch chicken and dumplings recipe–it’s a timeless favorite that’s sure to become a staple in your kitchen.

Imagine tender, chopped rotisserie chicken and thick, square dumplings floating in a rich, savory broth.

To make it even heartier, we add potatoes, carrots, and sweet peas, turning it into a full meal in one pot.

While it might seem like a complicated dish, especially with homemade dumplings from scratch, the good news is it all comes together in just under an hour.

Perfect for a cozy dinner that feels like a warm hug.

4.Amish Friendship Bread

Amish Friendship Bread is more than just a recipe–it’s a story and a tradition.

This sweet, cake-like bread is made using a starter that’s often passed from friend to friend, like a chain letter, but with a much sweeter outcome.

Instead of bad luck, you’ll get a delicious loaf to enjoy. The best part? You don’t need a starter from someone else to make it.

This version uses buttermilk to get things going, so you can bake a batch whenever the craving strikes. It’s moist, flavorful, and perfect for sharing–or not!

5.Amish Apple Fritter Bread

Step into fall with this irresistible apple fritter bread. Tender apples meet a crispy, golden-brown crust, all wrapped up in a warm blend of brown sugar and cinnamon.

Drizzled with a sweet vanilla glaze, this bread is a delicious way to kick off your morning.

6.Amish Cake

Meet your new go-to dessert: a classic cake that’s soft, fluffy, and moist. The real star? That ridiculously buttery brown sugar and nut topping. It’s so good, you’ll be tempted to go back for seconds!

7.Whoopie Pie

Meet your new obsession: chewy, soft-baked chocolate sandwiches stuffed with a light and airy, sweet filling. If you can’t choose between a cake and a cookie, you’re in luck–this is the perfect mashup of both.

These babies are so good, you’ll want to hide them from everyone else. Consider yourself warned: they’re seriously addictive!

8.Amish Pancakes

These pancakes are ridiculously light and fluffy – it’s like biting into a cloud! They’re perfect for breakfast, lunch, or even dinner (no judgments here!).

No matter what mix-ins or toppings you choose, these pancakes are always a winning combination. They’re the ultimate crowd-pleaser, any time of day!

9.Amish Potato Salad

Amish potato salad is a delicious mix of sweet, tangy, creamy, and savory flavors that everyone will love.

With potatoes and hard-boiled eggs as the stars, this hearty side dish pairs perfectly with any meat, from grilled meats to sandwiches.

It’s fancy enough for a party but simple enough to whip up any day of the week. Plus, one batch makes a big bowl, but don’t be surprised when it disappears in no time!

10.Amish Baked Beans

Cozy up on a chilly, rainy evening with these Amish baked beans–they’re the ultimate comfort food. These beans are tender and soft, nestled in a sauce that’s sweet, savory, and smoky all at once.

While they take some time to cook, the prep is a breeze. Perfect for a cozy night in or feeding a crowd, these beans are a hearty, satisfying treat that’s worth the wait.

11.Amish Macaroni Salad

Step right up to the tastiest party in town! 🎉 This Amish macaroni salad is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with elbow macaroni, hard-boiled eggs, crunchy pickles, sweet red peppers, and onions.

The magic happens in the dressing–a perfect mix of Miracle Whip, mustard, sugar, and vinegar that’s sweet, tangy, and totally irresistible.

Bring this creamy, dreamy dish to your next potluck, and get ready to wow the crowd!

12.Amish Ground Beef and Cabbage Skillet

Meet your new go-to skillet recipe! This vibrant, budget-friendly dish is packed with ground beef and cabbage for a hearty, flavorful meal that’s as easy on the wallet as it is to make.

The best part? Everything cooks up in just one pan, making prep and cleanup a breeze. It’s a simple yet satisfying dish that’s sure to become a family favorite.

And let’s not forget the cleanup–just one pan to wash means more time to enjoy the meal!

13.Amish Baked Chicken

Amish baked chicken is the ultimate comfort food that’s sure to impress! With its golden, crispy exterior and juicy, tender interior, this dish is a crowd-pleaser. The best part?

It’s baked, not fried, so you don’t have to spend hours tending to a hot stove. Just let the oven work its magic while you relax.

The result is so flavorful and satisfying, everyone will think you spent all day in the kitchen. It’s the perfect, hassle-free meal that’s sure to become a family favorite!

14.Amish Oatmeal Pie

Step back in time with this Civil War-era oatmeal pie, born from necessity when pecans were scarce. Not only is it budget-friendly, but it’s also irresistibly delicious.

The filling is a simple mix of brown sugar, butter, rolled oats, and milk. If you’re new to Amish pies, this is the perfect place to start.

Once baked, the filling transforms into a wonderfully gooey, sweet, and buttery treat that’s impossible to resist.

15.Amish Cabbage and Potato Casserole

Ground beef, potatoes, and cabbage team up to create a hearty, satisfying casserole. The cheesy slices on top add an extra layer of flavor and creaminess.

While it takes a little over an hour to bake, the end result is absolutely worth the wait.

16.Amish Sugar Cookies

End your day on a sweet note with these irresistible Amish sugar cookies. They’re tender, soft, and practically melt in your mouth–irresistible!

These cookies are as pretty as they are delicious, with a delicate appearance that’s sure to charm.

Enjoy them as they are, or get creative with toppings like sprinkles, colored sugar, or a tangy lemon glaze.

Perfectly sweet and oh-so-easy to customize, these cookies are a treat you’ll want to make again and again.

17.Amish Baked Oatmeal

Ready to elevate your oatmeal game? This baked oatmeal is a total game-changer! Made with rolled oats, maple syrup, cinnamon, and vanilla, it’s baked to golden perfection. The best part?

These squares hold their shape beautifully–like a giant oatmeal cookie. Whether you’re an oatmeal lover or not, this dish is sure to win you over. Perfect for breakfast or snacks, it’s a crowd-pleaser!

18.Amish White Bread

Homemade Amish white bread is a game-changer for your sandwich game. This loaf is ridiculously soft and fluffy, making it a total showstopper.

Plus, one batch gives you two loaves–perfect for when you’ve got a crowd to feed. Serve it up alongside a juicy roast beef, and you’ve got yourself a meal that’s pure perfection.

19.Amish Yumasetti Casserole

Meet Yumasetti, a classic Amish casserole that’s as fun to say as it is to eat!

This hearty dish typically features noodles and beef, and there are plenty of ways to make it–some recipes use tomato sauce, while others are topped with cheese.

In this version, you’ll mix ground beef, noodles, sour cream, and a creamy blend of cream of chicken and cream of mushroom soups. The result?

A super rich and indulgently creamy casserole that’s sure to become a family favorite. It’s comfort food at its finest, and it’s surprisingly easy to whip up for any meal!

20.Amish Broccoli Salad

Broccoli and cauliflower might not sound like a hit with kids at first, but trust me, this salad changes the game.

Toss those veggies with some crispy bacon, sharp cheddar, and a rich, creamy dressing, and you’ll have a dish even the pickiest eaters will devour.

The combination of colors, flavors, and textures is absolute perfection–I’d give it a 12/10! Plus, it disappears fast, so go ahead and double the batch. Your crowd will thank you!

21.Amish Apple Dumplings

Looking for a fresh spin on apple pie? These apple dumplings are a must-try! Sweet and tender apples are wrapped in a rich, buttery dough, then baked to golden perfection.

The pièce de résistance? A drizzle of cinnamon sugar syrup that takes the flavor to the next level. These dumplings are a delightful twist on a classic dessert!

22.Amish Buttermilk Biscuits

Flaky, buttery, and oh-so-flaky, these buttermilk biscuits are a game-changer for breakfast lovers. The best part? They’re ready in just 30 minutes thanks to a simple folding trick that makes all the difference.

Serve them up with a hearty sausage gravy or slather them in butter and honey–either way, they’re pure perfection.

23.Amish Chicken Corn Casserole

Imagine a dish that combines the creamiest chicken and corn with a buttery, cracker crunch. This chicken and corn casserole is comfort food at its absolute best.

The chicken and corn kernels are smothered in a rich, creamy, and buttery sauce that’s already a showstopper.

And let’s not forget the crowning glory: a golden layer of crushed Ritz crackers on top that takes it to a whole new level of deliciousness.

It’s the perfect dish to cozy up with, any day of the week.

24.Amish Caramel Corn

The Amish may not watch movies, but they sure know how to make amazing popcorn! This caramel corn is a perfect mix of sweet and salty, with a crunch that’s hard to resist.

It’s a fantastic snack for your next game night or a thoughtful gift for friends and family–they’ll love you for it!

25.Amish Apple Goodie

This apple crisp is a total showstopper! The aroma alone is enough to get your taste buds dancing. With a golden, buttery oatmeal streusel topping that’s perfectly crispy, this dessert is sure to impress.

One bite and you’ll be hooked!